Is Sonic the Hedgehog (1991) Still Worth Playing 33 Years Later?
Gettin' old there, Sonic.
A slightly altered version of this article originally appeared on Sega Does
Sonic the Hedgehog is a generational game changer. Like the original Star Wars or Super Mario Bros., millions of kids (myself included) can point to the original Sonic as the day their world stood still. The blue spiky hedgehog, as delivered to us in 1991, was just too cool, too fast, his world too vibrant and colorful. His game was both the brilliant present and an unprecedented future. Lush hills, ancient ruins, neon cities, and hyper-industrial hellscapes collide with endless swirling fantastical bonus zones, complete with LSD animal imagery. You didn’t just play Sonic. Sonic transported you into its confused, conflicted, and exquisitely realized world.
At age six, Sonic the Hedgehog was everything I ever wanted in a video game. Maybe that was the Sega marketing programming my young brain with brilliant blue deception, but I dunno, Sonic delivered for me. I didn’t care that the game was only half devil-may-care speed trickery, half unbelievably careful platforming. I didn’t care that Labyrinth Zone’s underwater slowed the pace to a crawl, or that Scrap Brain Zone doesn’t let you breathe in between bouts of buzzsaws, bombs, and flames. I controlled Sonic, Sonic was amazing, and because he was amazing, he could overcome anything. This is indeed how my young mind thought. Several decades later, I’m in awe of such beautiful, effortless optimism.
Whether in the games, movies, comics, or numerous television shows, Sonic’s main answers for overcoming obstacles are speed and snark. Sonic the Hedgehog only shows the occasional snark – finger wagging on the title screen, a glare when he’s not moving – but “gotta go fast” is Sonic’s signature from the get go. When he propels forward, speedy shoes power-up engaged, and you feel like you can’t control him anymore – what a rush! It feels like he’s going to blow through the level, off the screen, and into realms of infinity that only he can see… until he inevitably runs into a Crabmeat or a Caterkiller.
Ah, the rub. With great speed comes the need for great brakes, something the game conveys early on in Green Hill Zone. Springs appear when you’re at full momentum and propel you backwards. Platforms crumble beneath you and plunge you into spiky pits. Enemy projectiles emerge from nowhere and blast every ring out of your body. For a game that’s main marketing hook was moving quickly from level to level, the developers certainly punish you for going fast outside of certain jurisdictions.
Maybe Sonic the Hedgehog could have been a purely speed-focused experience, but it would have been a lesser game for it. Kids kept playing Sonic long after the speed-centered marketing had worn off because the game is just a damn good, never-been-done-before fusion of racing and platforming. Seriously kids, we’ve said it before and we’ll say it again: a game like Sonic the Hedgehog didn’t exist before June 1991. Platformers existed. Racing/driving games existed. But inserting “the fastest thing alive” into a platformer where he can both excel at his craft and learn to control himself in appropriate situations? For gamers, it was a near-perfect blend of the familiar with the unfamiliar. Sega would improve Sonic’s speedy, precise platforming in future Genesis outings, but the original Sonic the Hedgehog is a surprisingly excellent first attempt at a brand new style.
Then there are the zones, six wonderful, bizarre worlds with three acts each, and the reason for Sonic’s very existence. Let’s explore:
GREEN HILL ZONE
Sonic fans have likely played Green Hill Zone in no less than 27 Sonic games at this point. Still, this is the first Green Hill Zone and there’s no better introduction into Sonic the Hedgehog than this. With its emphasis on non-stop speed and thrusting Sonic into the heavens via tubes and loop-de-loops, it does its job at selling skeptics on the game’s potential. Also, the driving music still gets me going and the glistening water in the background remains a sublime visual effect.
MARBLE ZONE
Did Robotnik destroy whatever the Marble Zone used to be? Or did he just use these ancient ruins as a breeding ground for his animal/robot hybrids? Either way, Sonic’s gotta slow down almost immediately. The contemplative, moody soundtrack nicely complements the ruined area, which almost looks like something out of Altered Beast. Broken columns and underground passageways lead Sonic to unexplored territory. Sail on lava rivers, avoid the plunging spiky chandeliers, and make sure to step on the Caterkiller’s head. You know what will happen if you don’t.
SPRING YARD ZONE
Sonic’s fast and he’s shaped like a ball, thus the first of many pinball-inspired levels to come in the franchise. Spring Yard Zone is pretty choice. I love the perpetual twilight colors, the seemingly random words emblazoned onto the dusky sky (COPE is my favorite – what are you trying to say, Sega?), and the more upbeat pop music. This is supposed to be one of the faster zones, but hot dang, are there spikes and spiky enemies everywhere. Proceed with caution and a generous portion of funky freshness.
LABYRINTH ZONE
Everybody loves to hate this one, and I get it. Not only does Sonic have to be careful, but water both slows him down and slowly kills him. Still, I actually enjoy Labyrinth Zone. There are bubbles everywhere! It’s not hard to find air for Sonic! The key to progression here is just to move forward. No exploring, no veering off the path. Just collect air as needed and keep jumping up to the right. You’ll make it through eventually.
STAR LIGHT ZONE
Star Light Zone as a kid felt like endless nights, mood lighting, and possibilities, but now? It could use more stars and atmosphere and less dull gray-green pathways that clog up the area. It’s fun to bonk Sonic’s head against a folded-up staircase to make it descend, and the loop-de-loops make their triumphant return. Star Light Zone is not as serene as I remember, but it is a nice, short reprieve before the final showdown.
SCRAP BRAIN ZONE
“Caution” is probably a curse word in Sonic’s vocabulary, but Sonic’s not in control here, you are. Don’t let him move too fast. Between the electric shocks, the moving walkways, the flaming gas leaks, the platforms that drop unexpectedly, and probably some other stuff that can kill you, Robotnik’s clearly playing for keeps here. Those booming drums! The buzzing of the saws! Sonic should feel very afraid here, but he doesn’t because he is overly confident. Share his confidence and press on.
BONUS ZONE
Mario’s got all the mushrooms on lock, so Sonic had to go find himself something… stronger. After a dose or two, the emeralds are all in his imagination. Only by unlocking his mind and digging through all his abandoned hopes and dreams, scattered like forgotten gems within his inner universe, can Sonic reach his true prize: epiphany after colored epiphany. The emeralds are, in fact, not the key to some extra power outside of Sonic, but rather, the key to him unlocking his true potential. Gotta go… fast.
FINAL ZONE
Not a zone at all, really. This is the final Robotnik boss fight that’s easier than some of his previous incarnations. Robotnik comes down or goes up in one of four tubes. Hit the one he’s in, avoid the glowing electric balls, then hit him some more. You have no rings, so patience is key. As with the other fights, eight hits and he explodes, but not before he escapes in his egg capsule, like a sulking fat child.
FINAL THOUGHTS
I unapologetically love Sonic the Hedgehog. I love the character, the music, the worlds, the feel, the visuals, everything. I can’t even pretend to be objective about this game. It’s a stone-cold classic that, decades later, is still better than 90% of the other Sonic games out there (this is sad, but so it goes).
With Sonic the Hedgehog‘s massive success, Sega rose to the highest heights in the console industry. Sonic provided them resources, leverage, and hubris to ensure the early-90s gaming landscape looked just absolutely bonkers. Without Sonic, no success for Sega, and possibly, no 16-bit console war. Without Sonic, no success, and possibly no expecting your fan base to purchase expensive Genesis add-ons like the Sega CD and 32X. Without Sonic, Sega remains a premiere arcade game developer and a solid, if unremarkable, console maker.
Sonic the Hedgehog injected new life into the gaming industry, millions of children around the world, and its parent company. For that alone, it should be honored and celebrated for years to come.
Happy 33rd birthday, Sonic. You deserve all of your success.
It seems like Sega is the one company that is reluctant to milk their base franchise, and with Sonic, if they only had made more classic 2D ones or more Adventure games (the classic 3D, I say), then they could have done so much better.
Funny story: for a time, my oldest son understood Sonic to be the very definition of speed.
"Let's run together like two Sonics!" Or, "Daddy, our car is moving like Sonic!" Or, "Now it's time to use my Sonic speed!" This was mostly from watching me play Sonic Generations.
As for Sonic 1, I agree it has aged well, even if the level design is uneven. You can actually play it in Sonic Generations, and I've even beaten it in that format. Green Hill Zone's music is the best track on Genesis IMO.
I don't think there's another top-tier side-scrolling platformer with a move set as simple as Sonic 1. The power-ups don't add any moves to his arsenal (unlike Mario's Fire Flower, for example). No spin-dash or any other moves besides running and jumping. Only a single button is used. This can be an awkward adjustment at times, but it also lends the game a unique charm.
Though I think the water levels are a downside of this simplicity. It's unfortunate that Sonic's water sections started bad and never really got that much better, as I guess the later games felt locked into that original decision. This is one of the reasons that, while Sonic is great, Mario has always been king. In retrospect, the decision to give Mario an entirely different mode of movement in the water levels, to give them such a different and intense feel (despite that peaceful music), was a pretty amazing leap in a game that was already inventing a beloved genre.